Home
English VersionIrish Version
Search for Click to Search
Advanced Search
Printable Version
All SectionsPractice DirectionsCourt Rules Terms & Sittings
Legal Diary Offices & Maps Judgments & Determinations
Court of Appeal: 17th June 2019 Criminal


Criminal Appeals

Please note that with effect from Trinity term 2019 the Court will sit in Court 16, Criminal Courts of Justice, rather than Court 22.

List to Fix Dates and Management List
See Updated Notice in the Notices section of the Courts Service website as to the current arrangements for these Lists and for information as to the time for replying submissions and agreed Book of Authorities.

Practitioners are reminded of the terms of the Practice Direction (CA02) as published on the Courts Service
website governing materials for the use of the court in sentence appeals and undue leniency applications.

Practitioners are reminded of the requirement to serve on the Chief Prosecution Solicitor for the Director of Public Prosecutions written submissions lodged in the court office. Except for the documents referred to in Order 86C Rule 7 (1) (a notice of appeal or a notice of application pursuant to section 2 of the Criminal Procedure Act 1993) and in Order 86C Rule 15(1) (a notice of abandonment) notice of which the Registrar is required to give to various parties including the Chief Prosecution Solicitor all other documents lodged in the court office must be served on the Chief Prosecution Solicitor. Notice of any intended application to the Court must be given to the Chief Prosecution Solicitor as well as to the court office.

Civil Appeals
The attention of practitioners in civil appeals heard in the Criminal Courts of Justice is drawn to the terms of Practice Direction CA06 as published on the Courts Service website which came into effect on the 1st February 2017

TRINITY TERM (19th June to 31st July)

For Wednesday 19th of June 2019
In Court 16, Criminal Courts of Justice
The President
Mr Justice McCarthy
Ms Justice Kennedy
At 10.30 o'clock
Conviction Appeals
30/18 DPP -v- Patrick Roche (Connolly Finan Fleming Solicitors)
21/18 DPP -v- Philip Roche (Connolly Finan Fleming Solicitors)
2/18 DPP -v- Alan Freeman (O'Sullivan Kenny Solicitors)

The President
Mr Justice McCarthy
Ms Justice Kennedy
At 2.00 o'clock
Conviction Appeal - For mention only
40/12 DPP -v- Noel O'Connor (Sheehan & Partners Solicitors)
Sentence Appeal
317/18 DPP -v- Andrew Shannon (Cahir O'Higgins & Co Solicitors)
26/18 DPP -v- Eve Doherty (Sheehan & Partners Solicitors)

For Thursday 20th June 2019
In Court 16, Criminal Courts of Justice
The President
Mr Justice McCarthy
Ms Justice Kennedy
At 10.30 o'clock
Sentence Appeal
158/18 DPP -v- Alan Long (Fahy Bambury Solicitors)
265/17 DPP -v- Carl Cullen (John Feaheny & Co Solicitors)
Conviction & Sentence Appeal
245/18 DPP -v- Marek Grabowski (O'Dwyer Solicitors)

For Friday 21st June 2019
In Court 16, Criminal Courts of Justice
The President
At 10 o'clock
Case Management List
For Mention
54CJA/17 DPP-v-James Preston (Fahy Bambury Solicitors)
169/18 DPP -v- Christopher Redmond (Connolly Finan Fleming Solicitors)
78/19 DPP -v- Barry O'Donoghue (David Powderly Solicitors)
8CJA/18 DPP -v- Kieran Murray (Edward R. Bradbury Solicitors)
16CJA/18 DPP -v- Gerard Kelly (Herbert & Co Solicitors)
214/18 DPP -v- Steven Appleton (Philip Hannon Solicitors)
20/19 DPP -v- Sean Lane (Murphy Ramsay Walsh Solicitors)
212/18 DPP -v- Garreth Phillips (McMahon & Co Solicitors)
141/18 DPP -v- Glen Kiely (Connolly Finan Fleming Solicitors)
Motion
27/19 DPP -v- Joseph O'Connor (Cyril & Co Solicitors)
Enlargement of Time application
57/19 DPP -v- Paschal Kelly (Fahy Bambury Solicitors)
95/19 DPP -v- Daniel Wildes (Partners at Law Solicitors)
64/19 DPP -v- Frank Ryan (Tim Kennelly Solicitors)
Civil Appeal
2019 208 Ross -v- The Director of Public Prosecutions
2019 209 Wyatt -v- The Director of Public Prosecutions
2019 210 C -v- The Director of Public Prosecutions
2019 256 O'Donnell -v- The Director of Public Prosecutions
2019 260 The Director of Public Prosecutions -v- Ali Abdi

Ms Justice Whelan
Mr Justice McCarthy
Ms Justice Kennedy
At 10.30 o'clock
Sentence Appeal
221/18 DPP -v- Wesley Purse (John M. Joy & Co Solicitors)
164/18 DPP -v- John Delaney (Barry Fitzgerald Solicitors)
155/17 DPP -v- Bernard Donovan (Tim Kennelly Solicitors)
Conviction Appeal
220/17 DPP -v- Alan Cawley (Damien Rudden Solicitors)

For Monday 24th June 2019
In Court 16, Criminal Courts of Justice
The President
Mr Justice Edwards
Mr Justice McCarthy
At 10.30 o'clock
Undue Leniency Application
94CJA/18 DPP -v- Jamie Coughlan (Newell Gillen & Cunningham Solicitors)
Sentence Appeal
85/18 DPP -v- Thomas Healy (Diarmuid Kelleher & Co Solicitors)
Conviction & Sentence Appeal
31/17 DPP -v- Andrew Reilly (Kevin Tunney & Co Solicitors)

For Tuesday 25th June 2019
In Court 16, Criminal Courts of Justice
The President
Mr Justice Edwards
Ms Justice Whelan
At 10.30 o'clock
Sentence Appeal
322/18 DPP -v- Barry Watters (MacGuill & Co Solicitors)
323/18 DPP -v- William Butler (French Kenny Solicitors)
Conviction & Sentence Appeal
169/16 DPP -v- Joseph Hogan (Herbert & Co Solicitors)
Civil Appeal
2019 236 The Minister for Justice and Equality -V- McArdle
2019 239 The Minister for Justice and Equality -v- Pal

For Thursday 27th June 2019
In Court 16, Criminal Courts of Justice
Mr Justice Edwards
Ms Justice Whelan
Mr Justice McCarthy
At 10.30 o'clock
Civil Appeals For hearing
1. 2017 446 Brigid Quinn -v- Allied Irish Banks plc & Ors (motion + appeal for mention)
2. 2014 1182 Michael Quinn & Brigid Quinn -v- Fennell (motion + appeal for mention)
3. 2017 33 Michael Quinn & Brigid Quinn -v- McDonough Breen Solrs & Ors (motion + appeal for mention)
4. 2015 334 Ulster Bank Ireland -v- Michael Quinn & Brigid Quinn (motion + appeal for mention)
5. 2014 1383 Allied Irish Banks -v- Brigid Quinn & anor (motion + appeal for mention)
6. 2017 34 Michael Quinn & Brigid Quinn -v- Allied Irish Banks plc & Ors (motion + appeal for mention)
7. 2014 828 Allied Irish Banks plc -v- Michael Quinn & Brigid Quinn
Undue Leniency Applications
8CJA/18 DPP -v- Kieran Murray (Edward R. Bradbury Solicitors)
16CJA/18 DPP -v- Gerard Kelly (Herbert & Co Solicitors)

For Friday 28th June 2019
In Court 16, Criminal Courts of Justice
The President
At 10 o'clock
Case Management List
For Review
151/13 DPP -v- Brian Shaughnessy (Siuna Bartels & Co Solicitors)
For Mention
244/18 DPP -v- Christina Joyce (French Kenny Solicitors)
217/18 DPP -v- Laurence Carthy (Burns Nowlan Solicitors)
171/15 DPP -v- Sean Farrell (Siuna Bartels & Co Solicitors)
218/12 DPP -v- Gerard Hayes (Siuna Bartels & Co Solicitors)
Civil Appeal
2019 240 Midnight Entertainment Limited -v- DPP
2019 270 Anthony McGrath -v- DPP

The President
Mr Justice Edwards
Mr Justice McCarthy
At 10.30 o'clock
Undue Leniency For Further Hearing
75CJA/17 DPP -v- Ian Murrihy (Kieran O'Brien Solicitors)
Conviction & Sentence Appeal
246/18 DPP -v- Mark Carlisle (Niall O'Connor & Co Solicitors)
Conviction Appeal
224/15 DPP -v- David Cully (O'Connor Buckley & Co Solicitors)
Sentence Appeal
119/18 DPP -v- Patrick Harty (Sheehan & Partners Solicitors)

For Monday 1st July 2019
In Court 16, Criminal Courts of Justice
The President
Ms Justice Whelan
Mr Justice McCarthy
At 10.30 o'clock
Undue Leniency Application
For further hearing
138CJA/18 DPP -V- Stephen Sarsfield (Sheehan & Partners Solicitors)
Sentence Appeal
152/18 DPP -v- William Power (Madden & Finucane Solicitors)
137/16 DPP -v- Leroy Dumbrell (aka Leroy Roche) (John M. Quinn & Co Solicitors)
Enlargement of Time Application
7/19 DPP -v- Sarah Doran (Kieran Conway Solicitors)

For Tuesday 2nd July 2019
In Court 16, Criminal Courts of Justice
The President
Mr Justice Edwards
Ms Justice Kennedy
At 10.30 o'clock
Sentence Appeal
5/19 DPP -v- Alice Byrne (Phillip Hannon Solicitors)
Conviction & Sentence Appeal
210/18 DPP -v- Martin Sherlock (Barry Fitzgerald Solicitors)
50/17 DPP -v- Paul Kearney (Connolly Finan Fleming Solicitors)
Sentence Appeal
305/18 DPP -v- Mark Bissett (John M. Quinn & Co Solicitors)

For Wednesday 3rd July 2019
In Court 16, Criminal Courts of Justice
Mr Justice Peart
Mr Justice Edwards
Ms Justice Kennedy
At 10.00 o'clock
Sentence Appeal
258/17 DPP -v- M.S. (Sheehan & Partners Solicitors)

For Thursday 4th July 2019
In Court 16, Criminal Courts of Justice
The President
Mr Justice Edwards
Ms Justice Kennedy
At 10.30 o'clock
Sentence Appeal
267/18 DPP -v- Cillian Barry (Michael E. Hanahoe Solicitors)
Conviction & Sentence Appeal
12/18 DPP -v- Joseph Doocey (cctv)

For Friday 5th July 2019
In Court 16, Criminal Courts of Justice
The President
At 10 o'clock
Case Management List
For Mention
27/19 DPP -v- Joseph O'Connor (Cyril & Co Solicitors)
Enlargement of time application
13/19 DPP -v- Ray Dore (French Kenny Solicitors)
58/19 DPP -v- Mamour Lowe Nicolas (John M. Quinn & Co Solicitors)

The President
Ms Justice Whelan
Ms Justice Kennedy
At 10.30 o'clock
Sentence Appeal
130/18 DPP -v- Peter Kernan (Connolly Finan Fleming Solicitors)
Conviction & Sentence Appeal
163/18 DPP -v- David Byrne (Anthony Collier Solicitors)
207/18 DPP -v- Teymur Babayev (Kevin Tunney & Co Solicitors)

For Monday 15th July 2019
In Court 16, Criminal Courts of Justice
Mr Justice Edwards
Ms Justice Whelan
Mr Justice McCarthy
At 10.30 o'clock
Undue Leniency Application
175CJA/18 DPP -v- K.K. (O'Kelly Moylan Solicitors)
319CJA/18 DPP -v- Ryan Callaghan (Anthony Collier Solicitors)
320CJA/18 DPP -v- Mark Parkes (Edward R. Bradbury Solicitors)

For Tuesday 16th July 2019
In Court 16, Criminal Courts of Justice
The President
Mr Justice Edwards
Mr Justice McCarthy
At 10.30 o'clock
Conviction Appeal
241/18 & 253CJA/18 DPP -v- Edward O'Brien (Fahy Bambury Solicitors)
226/18 & 252CJA/18 DPP -v- David Nooney (Michael E. Hanahoe Solicitors)
254/18 DPP -v- Eva Shannon (Phoenix Law)
251/18 DPP -v- Kevin Hannaway (Phoenix Law)
240/18 DPP -v- Sean Hannaway (Michael Finucane Solicitors)

For Wednesday 17th July 2019
In Court 16, Criminal Courts of Justice
The President
Mr Justice Edwards
Mr Justice McCarthy
At 10.30 o'clock
Conviction Appeal
241/18 & 253CJA/18 DPP -v- Edward O'Brien (Fahy Bambury Solicitors)
226/18 & 252CJA/18 DPP -v- David Nooney (Michael E. Hanahoe Solicitors)
254/18 DPP -v- Eva Shannon (Phoenix Law)
251/18 DPP -v- Kevin Hannaway (Phoenix Law)
240/18 DPP -v- Sean Hannaway (Michael Finucane Solicitors)

For Thursday 18th July 2019
In Court 16, Criminal Courts of Justice
The President
Mr Justice Edwards
Mr Justice McCarthy
At 10.30 o'clock
Conviction Appeal
241/18 & 253CJA/18 DPP -v- Edward O'Brien (Fahy Bambury Solicitors)
226/18 & 252CJA/18 DPP -v- David Nooney (Michael E. Hanahoe Solicitors)
254/18 DPP -v- Eva Shannon (Phoenix Law)
251/18 DPP -v- Kevin Hannaway (Phoenix Law)
240/18 DPP -v- Sean Hannaway (Michael Finucane Solicitors)

For Friday 19th July 2019
In Court 16, Criminal Courts of Justice
The President
At 10 o'clock
Case Management List
For Mention
117/14 DPP -v- Peter Barry (Burns Nowlan Solicitors)
268/18 DPP -v- Robert Scott (Cyril & Co Solicitors)
214/13 DPP -v- John Dundon (Kieran O'Brien Solicitors)
Motion
10/18 DPP -v- Clement Limen (Cyril & Co Solicitors)
For Review
106/14 DPP -v- Andrzej Benko (Sheehan & Partners Solicitors)
Civil Appeal
2019 190 Fitzgerald -V- O'Donnabhain & Anor

The President
Mr Justice Peart
Ms Justice Kennedy
At 10.30 o'clock
Undue Leniency Application
145CJA/18 DPP -v- Darren De Lacey (Michael Kelleher Solicitors)
Sentence Appeal
244/18 DPP -v- Christina Joyce (French Kenny Solicitors)
265/18 DPP -v- Patrick McMorrow (Fahy Bambury Solicitors)
Conviction & Sentence Appeal
72/18 DPP -v- Brendan O'Brien (Edmund J. Burke & Co Solicitors)

For Monday 22nd July 2019
In Court 16, Criminal Courts of Justice
The President
At 10 o'clock
List to Fix Dates
For Mention
106/11 DPP -v- Stephen Walsh (Cyril & Co Solicitors)
225/18 DPP -v- Ciaran Maguire (Michael E Hanahoe Solicitors)
233/18 DPP -v- Kevin Braney (Shalom Binchey & Co Solicitors)
Sentence Appeal
9/14 DPP -v- Aaron Gabbett (Caroline Egan Solicitor)
14/17 DPP -v- Dónall Billings (Bríd Mimnagh & Associates Solicitors)
64/18 DPP -v- Valerij Safonov (Aonghus McCarthy Solicitor)
252/17 DPP -v- Richard Folan (Hennessey & Perozzi Solicitors)
Enlargement of Time Application
281CJA/17 DPP -v- Roger Ryan (Fahy Bambury Solicitors)
Conviction Appeal
10/18 DPP -v- Clement Limen (Cyril & Co Solicitors)
104/17 DPP -v- Michael Casey (Midland Legal Solicitors)
Civil Appeals
2019 21 O'Toole -v- Governor of Castlerea Prison & Ors (on Bail)

The President
Mr Justice McCarthy
Ms Justice Kennedy
At 11 o'clock
Sentence Appeal
256/17 DPP -v- Denis O'Sullivan (Edmund J. Burke & Co Solicitors)
For Sentence
161CJA/18 DPP -v- Aurelijus Kizelavicius (Michael B. O'Donnell Solicitors)
Conviction Appeal
40/12 DPP -v- Noel O'Connor (Sheehan & Partners Solicitors)

For Tuesday 23rd July 2019
In Court 16, Criminal Courts of Justice
Mr Justice Edwards
Mr Justice McCarthy
Ms Justice Kennedy
At 10.30 o'clock
Sentence Appeal
150/18 DPP -v- Molly Sloyan (John Feaheny & Co Solicitors)
308/18 DPP -v- Liam O'Connell (Frank Buttimer & Co Solicitors)
Conviction & Sentence Appeal
55/17 DPP -v- Gavin Sheehan (Frank Buttimer & Co Solicitors)
Civil Appeal
2018 33 Corrigan -v- DPP

For Thursday 25th July 2019
In Court 16, Criminal Courts of Justice
The President
Mr Justice McCarthy
Ms Justice Kennedy
At 10.30 o'clock
Conviction Appeal
15/13 DPP -v- Michael McDonald (KOD Lyons Solicitors)
Sentence Appeal
112/18 DPP -v- Tibor Hricko (Burns Nowlan & Co Solicitors)

The President
Mr Justice McCarthy
Ms Justice Kennedy
Sentence Appeal
153/18 DPP -v- Mark O'Sullivan (Brendan Maloney Solicitors)

For Friday 26th July 2019
In Court 16, Criminal Courts of Justice
The President
Mr Justice Peart
Mr Justice McCarthy
At 10.30 o'clock
Sentence Appeal
170/15 DPP -v- Seosamh O'Ceallaigh (Sheehan & Partners Solicitors)
73/18 DPP -v- Scott O'Donovan (Edmund J. Burke & Co Solicitors)
305/16 DPP -v- Roger Ryan (Fahy Bambury Solicitors)
262/18 DPP -v- Christopher Black (John M. Quinn & Co Solicitors)

For Monday 29th July 2019
In Court 16, Criminal Courts of Justice
Mr Justice Peart
Mr Justice Edwards
Ms Justice Kennedy
At 10.30 o'clock
Sentence Appeal
214/15 DPP -v- Klass Meijvogel (Conway Solicitors)
Sentence Appeal & Undue Leniency Application
12/19 & 16CJA/19 DPP -v- Tamodaven Sanassee (Martin & Gately Solicitors)

For Tuesday 30th July 2019
In Court 16, Criminal Courts of Justice
The President
Mr Justice Edwards
Ms Justice Kennedy
At 10.30 o'clock
Sentence Appeal
220/18 DPP -v- Shane Costello (Fiona D'Arcy & Co Solicitors)
Conviction Appeal
224/18 DPP -v- Adam Marlowe (John Feaheny & Co Solicitors)
206/16 DPP -v- Krzystof Grzegorski (Cahir O'Higgins & Co Solicitors)

For Wednesday 31st July 2019
In Court 16, Criminal Courts of Justice
Mr Justice Edwards
Ms Justice Whelan
Ms Justice Kennedy
At 10.30 o'clock
Civil Appeal
2018 244 Maher -v- DPP

MICHAELMAS TERM (7th October to 20th December)

For Tuesday 8th October 2019
In Court 16, Criminal Courts of Justice
At 10.30 o'clock
Sentence Appeal
307/18 DPP -v- Donna Dineen (Aonghus McCarthy Solicitors)
149/18 DPP -v- Anthony Cassidy (O'Flaherty Brown Solicitors)
Conviction & Sentence Appeal
219/18 DPP -v- John Conroy (Cahir O'Higgins & Co Solicitors)

For Thursday 10th October 2019
In Court 16, Criminal Courts of Justice
At 10.30 o'clock
Sentence Appeal
96/18 DPP -v- Jim Byrne (Siobhan Conlon Solicitor)
Civil Appeal
2019 85 Farrell -v- Superintendent of Milford Garda Station & MJE
2019 86 Maguire -v- Superintendent of Letterkenny Garda Station & MJE

For Friday 11th October 2019
In Court 16, Criminal Courts of Justice
At 10.30 o'clock
Conviction & Sentence Appeal
157/17 DPP -v- Paul Kearney (Connolly Finan Solicitors)

For Monday 14h October 2019
In Court 16, Criminal Courts of Justice
At 10.30 o'clock
Sentence Appeal
202/18 DPP -v- Martin Conroy (Michael McDarby & Co Solicitors)
97/18 DPP -v- Adam Whelan (Connolly Finan Fleming Solicitors)

For Tuesday 15h October 2019
In Court 16, Criminal Courts of Justice
At 10.30 o'clock
Sentence Appeal
188/18 DPP -v- Ian O'Sullivan (John M. Joy Solicitors)
Conviction Appeal
94/17 DPP -v- Roy Webster (Jonathan Dunphy & Co Solicitors)

For Thursday 17th October 2019
In Court 16, Criminal Courts of Justice
At 10.30 o'clock
Civil Appeal
2019 73 Pakenham & Ors -v- Chief Inspector of Social Services

For Tuesday 22nd October 2019
In Court 16, Criminal Courts of Justice
At 10.30 o'clock
Conviction & Sentence Appeal
259/18 DPP -v- Thomas Geoghegan (Phelim O'Neill Solicitors)

For Thursday 24th October 2019
In Court 16, Criminal Courts of Justice
At 10.30 o'clock
Conviction & Sentence Appeal
214/18 DPP -v- Steven Appleton (Philip Hannon Solicitors)

For Tuesday 29h October 2019
In Court 16, Criminal Courts of Justice
At 10.30 o'clock
Conviction Appeal
227/18 DPP -v- David Byrne (Michael Staines & Co Solicitors)
228/18 DPP -v- Mark Farrelly (Sheehan & Partners Solicitors)
223/18 DPP -v- Niall Byrne (Kevin Tunney Solicitors)

For Wednesday 30th October 2019
In Court 16, Criminal Courts of Justice
At 10.30 o'clock
Conviction Appeal
227/18 DPP -v- David Byrne (Michael Staines & Co Solicitors)
228/18 DPP -v- Mark Farrelly (Sheehan & Partners Solicitors)
223/18 DPP -v- Niall Byrne (Kevin Tunney Solicitors)

For Thursday 31st October 2019
In Court 16, Criminal Courts of Justice
At 10.30 o'clock
Conviction Appeal
227/18 DPP -v- David Byrne (Michael Staines & Co Solicitors)
228/18 DPP -v- Mark Farrelly (Sheehan & Partners Solicitors)
223/18 DPP -v- Niall Byrne (Kevin Tunney Solicitors)

For Friday 1st November 2019
In Court 16, Criminal Courts of Justice
At 10.30 o'clock
Sentence Appeal
275/18 DPP -v- Peter Loftus (Jenny McGeever Solicitor)
Civil Appeal
2018 325 Bita -v- DPP, Ireland & AG
2019 191 De Jesus -v- The Commissioner of An Garda Síochána & anor

For Tuesday 26th November 2019
In Court 16, Criminal Courts of Justice
At 10.30 o'clock
Civil Appeal
2018 27 Lavery -v- District Judge McLoughlin
2018 39 Lavery -v- District Judge McLoughlin
2018 103 Lavery -v- DPP
2018 104 Lavery -v- DPP
2018 105 Lavery -v- DPP
2018 239 Lavery -v- District Judge MacBride & Anor
2018 240 Lavery -v- District Judge MacBride & Anor
2018 453 Lavery -v- District Judge MacBride
2019 106 Lavery -V- District Judge Denis McLoughlin & Anor

For Thursday 28th November 2019
In Court 16, Criminal Courts of Justice
At 10.30 o'clock
Conviction Appeal
316/18 DPP -v- Stephen Tynan (Connolly Finan Fleming Solicitors)
313/18 DPP -v- Raymond Fitzgerald (Fahy Bambury Solicitors)

For Friday 29th November 2019
In Court 16, Criminal Courts of Justice
At 10.30 o'clock
Conviction Appeal
316/18 DPP -v- Stephen Tynan (Connolly Finan Fleming Solicitors)
313/18 DPP -v- Raymond Fitzgerald (Fahy Bambury Solicitors)

For Monday 2nd December 2019
In the Courthouse Angelsea Street Cork
Undue Leniency Applications
312CJA/18 DPP -v- Michael Ferris (Frank Buttimer & Solicitors)

For Monday 16th December 2019
In Court 16, Criminal Courts of Justice
The President
At 10 o'clock
List to Fix Dates

For Tuesday 17th December 2019
In Court 16, Criminal Courts of Justice
The President
Mr Justice Edwards
Ms Justice Kennedy
At 10.00o'clock
For Review
124CJA/18 DPP -v- John Matthews (Partners at Law Solicitors)

For Thursday 19th December 2019
In Court 16, Criminal Courts of Justice
At 10.30 o'clock
Conviction & Sentence Appeal
286/18 DPP -v- Jonathan Hawthorn (Sheehan & Partners Solicitors)
51/16 DPP -v- Daniel Wyse (John Shanley Solicitors)